Wednesday 3 June 2015

Error occurs when CTE Alias is ‘RESULT’ - Incorrect syntax near 'RESULT'

Few days back one of my colleague ran into a very strange issue when he was asked to do an alteration to an existing procedure. The procedure was having a SELECT statement which included few Common Table Expressions. It has been running without an issue, until we tried to save the alteration. The alteration was a pretty simple one which was just to add couple of more columns. The query was similar to the one shown below

    /* Your logic  */

How ever when we tried to save the changes, it was throwing the following error.

Msg 102, Level 15, State 1, Line 2
Incorrect syntax near 'RESULT'.

But when we go through the query we couldn’t find any issues, and it seems the syntax was quite accurate. So we tried a different server and was able to save the changes without any error. The only difference was one server was running SQL Server 2012 which is having a higher build

Works fine on the following build

Microsoft SQL Server 2012 - 11.0.5058.0 (X64)
    May 14 2014 18:34:29
    Copyright (c) Microsoft Corporation
    Developer Edition (64-bit) on Windows NT 6.1 <X64> (Build 7601: Service Pack 1) (Hypervisor)

Throws an error on the following build

Microsoft SQL Server 2012 - 11.0.2100.60 (X64)
    Feb 10 2012 19:39:15
    Copyright (c) Microsoft Corporation
    Developer Edition (64-bit) on Windows NT 6.1 <X64> (Build 7601: Service Pack 1) (Hypervisor)

And when googled we could find that ‘RESULT’ is a future reserved keyword:


But we were still left out with a question of why it failed on an earlier build but succeeded on a most recent build. Please feel free to comment on this if you have further information.

Wednesday 20 May 2015

Conflict in log4net on GAC when a Crystal Report is viewed through .Net Code

We faced an issue sometime ago, which put us into a very tight situation. The issue was when a Crystal Report file is loaded through .Net code it threw the following error. This is the first of a series of error which lead to another and so forth.

System.Reflection.TargetInvocationException: Exception has been thrown by the target of an invocation.
---> System.TypeInitializationException: The type initializer for 'CrystalDecisions.ReportSource.ReportSourceFactory' threw an exception.
---> System.TypeInitializationException: The type initializer for 'CrystalDecisions.Shared.SharedUtils' threw an exception.
---> System.IO.FileLoadException: Could not load file or assembly 'log4net, Version=, Culture=neutral,
PublicKeyToken=692fbea5521e1304' or one of its dependencies. The located assembly's manifest definition does not match the assembly reference.
(Exception from HRESULT: 0x80131040)
File name: 'log4net, Version=, Culture=neutral, PublicKeyToken=692fbea5521e1304'
   at CrystalDecisions.Shared.SharedUtils..cctor()


And the confusion grew even further when we checked the GAC (Global Assembly Cache). Because we could see that in GAC, the mentioned assembly (log4net) is being registered with the version and with the correct ‘PublicKeyToken’ (692fbea5521e1304).


And we didn’t really worry about the ‘Processor Architecture’ column, since our development environment is 64-bit and all the Crystal Reports development pre-requisites were there in the development environment and Crystal Runtime was already installed (version 13 – 64-bit). And in our application code we were using the same log4net and it was already presented in the bin folder.

Then when we googled the issue we could be able to come across with similar incidents, where the majority of the people were able to resolve the issue by installing the Crystal Runtime. But it was sort of a puzzle to us since we already had it installed it. But later we tried by un-installing the runtime and re-installing it again, assuming some corruption might had occur during the previous installation or afterwards. But the result was same.

Then we came across with the following article which gave us some kind of a hint of the issue we are facing:

And it occurred to us that even though we had the same assembly which the error is pointing installed in GAC, still the Crystal assemblies were expecting some other log4net assembly to be presented in GAC.

Therefore we installed the Crystal Runtime version 13 for 32-bit. Afterwards the GAC was having both the assemblies registered.


And this resolved the issue. And we came to a conclusion that even our development environment is 64-Bit, we need to have the log4net assembly for 32-bit since crystal is referring to that internally.

Hope this would help you if you are facing the same problem.

Monday 5 November 2012

Create a Cursor using Dynamic SQL Query

Even though we are advised not to use or to minimize the usage of cursors in SQL, there are times which, it’s the only available option, depending on the task and the situation. But there are times you are required to build the cursor using a dynamic SQL select statement.

To illustrate this, i will create two tables and populated it with sample data.

--==== Create sample tables ====--
create table sample_table_a(
    id        int
    ,name    varchar(50)
create table sample_table_b(
    id            int
    ,country    varchar(50)
--==== Populate with sample data ====--
insert into sample_table_a (id,name)
values(1,'Windows'),(2,'Mac OS'),(3,'Linux')
insert into sample_table_B(id,country)


When creating a cursor using dynamic query, initially the cursor should be declared and passed on to the dynamic query execution.

/* ==== Variable Declaration ==== */
declare @objcursor as cursor 
    @vsql        as nvarchar(max)
    ,@vquery    as nvarchar(max)
    ,@id        as int
    ,@value        as varchar(50)
/* ==== Sample Table A ==== */
set @vquery = 'select id, name from sample_table_a'
set @vsql = 'set @cursor = cursor forward_only static for ' + @vquery + ' open @cursor;'
exec sys.sp_executesql
    ,N'@cursor cursor output'
    ,@objcursor output
fetch next from @objcursor into @id,@value
while (@@fetch_status = 0)
    print cast(@id as varchar) + ' - ' + @value
    fetch next from @objcursor into @id,@value
close @objcursor
deallocate @objcursor
/* ==== Sample Table B ==== */
set @vquery = 'select id, country from sample_table_b'
set @vsql = 'set @cursor = cursor forward_only static for ' + @vquery + ' open @cursor;'
exec sys.sp_executesql
    ,N'@cursor cursor output'
    ,@objcursor output
fetch next from @objcursor into @id,@value
while (@@fetch_status = 0)
    print cast(@id as varchar) + ' - ' + @value
    fetch next from @objcursor into @id,@value
close @objcursor
deallocate @objcursor


Also you can create a procedure which will return you a cursor taking the selection query as a parameter.

CREATE PROCEDURE [dbo].[Gsp_Create_GenericCursor]
    /* Parameters */
    @vQuery        NVARCHAR(MAX)
        @vSQL        AS NVARCHAR(MAX)
    SET @vSQL = 'SET @Cursor = CURSOR FORWARD_ONLY STATIC FOR ' + @vQuery + ' OPEN @Cursor;'
    EXEC sp_executesql
         ,N'@Cursor cursor output'  
         ,@Cursor OUTPUT;

Use the following syntax to use the above mentioned procedure

    EXEC dbo.Gsp_Create_GenericCursor 
        ,@Cursor = @obj OUTPUT
        FETCH NEXT FROM @obj INTO @i
        WHILE (@@FETCH_STATUS = 0)
            PRINT @i
            FETCH NEXT FROM @obj INTO @i
        CLOSE @obj
        DEALLOCATE @obj

Wednesday 19 September 2012

Introduction to SSDT (SQL Server Data Tools)

What is SSDT ?

SQL Server Data Tools (SSDT) is a toolset which provides an integrated environment for database developers to carry out all their database design work for any SQL Server platform (both on and off premise) within Visual Studio. Database developers can use the SQL Server Object Explorer in VS to easily create or edit database objects and data, or execute queries.

In a previous blog entry I have described on how to install SSDT into the VS environment. During this I will briefly describe few of it’s features.

SSDT’s intention is not to replace the SQL Server Management Studio, but provide a developer a complete development environment, which the developer need not required to leave Visual Studio IDE to do any database related development. The tool does not contain all the features which you find in SSMS, yet it’ll provide sufficient functionality which will required to most of the developers during their development tasks.

I find following features, pretty  much interesting and helps to increase the productivity of the developer/team.


1. Design & Code view in a single screen.


Ability to see the design view and the code view in a single screen is a wonderful thing. You do not have to move across screens. And the changes you do to the design view will be affected to the code immediately and vice versa.


2. Ability to add Constraints, Indexes, Foreign Keys & Triggers without changing the screen

Adding constraints, indexes, etc.. are much easier. You can add those by right clicking and choosing the ‘add <object>’ menu like shown below.



3. It uses ‘Declarative – Model Based Development’

What this means is that there is always an in-memory representation of what a database looks like—an SSDT database model— and all the SSDT tools (designers, validations, IntelliSense, schema compare, and so on) operate on that model. This model can be populated by a live connected database (on-premise or SQL Azure), an offline database project under source control, or a point-in-time snapshot taken of an offline database project (you will work with snapshots in the upcoming exercises). But to reiterate, the tools are agnostic to the model’s backing; they work exclusively against the model itself. Thus, you enjoy a rich, consistent experience in any scenario—regardless of whether you’re working with on-premise or cloud databases, offline projects, or versioned snapshots.


4. Connected Development

Although SSDT places great emphasis on the declarative model, it in no way prevents you from working imperatively against live databases when you want or need to. You can open query windows to compose and execute T-SQL statements directly against a connected database, with the assistance of a debugger if desired, just as you can in SSMS.



5. Disconnected Development

The new SQL Server Object Explorer lets you connect to and interact with any database right from inside Visual Studio. But SSDT offers a great deal more than a mere replacement for the connected SSMS experience. It also delivers a rich offline experience with the new SQL Server Database Project type and local database runtime (LocalDB).

Actually this is one great feature it has. Because due to many reasons, most of the time we are requested to work offline, or to do our development locally and later on merged. So this feature allows us to maintain a local database and do all the development using that. And later on merged/published to other database. And by doing a schema comparison, it’s possible to find out the changes we have done.



6. Schema Comparison

This is a very valuable feature. This allows us to do a schema comparison between our development environment and the physical database (or vice versa) and find out the changes very quickly.



7. Saving snapshots of the Database

Sometimes it’s required to keep snapshots of your database at different stages of the development. And the best thing is, it even allows you to compare between two database snapshots. So it’s easy to see the changes you have done compared to the previous stages.


8. Ability to find any errors or reference issues in design time

When SSDT is used it’s easy to identify any syntax issue or any reference issue before deploying it to the database. E.g. assume we have one view which is referring to few columns of a table. Usually if someone change or remove any columns from the table which this view is referring, there is no way of identify that, till the view is used in our application. But when SSDT is used, it will show you these issues, when building the project. So these can be eliminated before we apply these to the deployment server.


These are some features which I have find very interesting and most developers expect. But having said that I am not saying it’s the complete set of features. There are few missing functionalities which I felt that it would have been even nicer, if those were there.

And you can find a good article in here ( regarding the SSDT. You can find things in more depth.

Friday 31 August 2012

Installing SQL Server Data Tools (SSDT)

What is SQL Server Data Tools?

SQL Server Data Tools (SSDT) is a toolset which provides an integrated environment for database developers to carry out all their database design work for any SQL Server platform (both on and off premise) within Visual Studio. Database developers can use the SQL Server Object Explorer in VS to easily create or edit database objects and data, or execute queries.

More details are available regarding it’s features at

SSDT is not intended to be a replacement for SSMS, but instead can be viewed much more as a greatly evolved implementation of DbPro. Indeed, SSMS is alive and well in SQL Server 2012, and it continues to serve as the primary management tool for database administrators who need to configure and maintain healthy SQL Server installations.

However SSDT does not get installed with either Visual Studio or SQL Server. Instead, SSDT ships separately via the Web Platform Installer (WebPI).

  1. Download SSDT from
  2. Once it’s downloaded, open a command window with administrative privileges (run cmd.exe as Administrator), and execute the following command :

SSDTSetup.exe /layout <destination>

<destination> is the path which the WebPI will download all the necessary installation files and create the administrative installation point. This can be a location in either LAN, USB or your Local Drive.


Then it’ll start to download the required files to the given location.


Once everything is downloaded you can execute the ‘SSDTSetup.exe’ from the destination location. (without any arguments). Once the installation is completed successfully, you can see the tool in Visual Studio 2010 development environment. Select it from the ‘View’ menu.



Wednesday 11 April 2012

Resolved ~ How to get back SSMS ‘Find and Replace’ Alert


As you know in SQL Server Management Studio (SSMS), once you have cleared the check box value of ‘Always show this message’, from the ‘Find and Replace’ alert, there’s no way of getting it back.


If you remove the check box, instead of the alert you will get a message no the status bar as shown below.


But there’s a workaround to fix this problem. Do the following steps

1. Close all the SSMS environments. (If you have opened)
2. Open the registry editor and locate the key '\HKEY_CURRENT_USER\Software\Microsoft\Microsoft SQL Server\100\Tools\Shell\Find'.
3. Change the value of 'HitReplaced' to '1'


Thursday 8 March 2012

Locks and Duration of Transactions in MS SQL Server


It is a common argument which I hear among developers these days, regarding SQL locks. Some say that the ‘locks are held for the duration of the entire transaction’. But others debate that ‘locks will be only held for the duration of the statement execution’. But who is correct ?

Well both parties are correct up to a certain point. Actually lock durations are depend on the Isolation Levels.

As mentioned in the SQL-99 Standards, there are 4 Transaction Isolation Levels

  • Read Committed (Default)
  • Read Uncommitted
  • Repeatable Read
  • Serializable

SQL Server** provides following two additional isolation levels (** SQL Server 2005 & Upwards)

  • Snapshot
  • Read Committed Snapshot

There are several concurrency issues which can occur in a DBMS when multiple users try to access the same data. Each isolation level protects against a specific concurrency problem.

  • Lost Update
  • Dirty Read
  • Non-Repeatable Read
  • Phantom Reads


Lost Update – This can take place in two ways. First scenario: it can take place when data that has been updated by one transaction (Transaction A), overwritten by another transaction (Transaction B), before the Transaction A commits or rolls back. (But this type of lost update can never occur in SQL Server** under any transaction isolation level)


The second scenario is when one transaction (Transaction A) reads a record and retrieve the value into a local variable and that same record will be updated by another transaction (Transaction B). And later Transaction A will update the record using the value in the local variable. In this scenario the update done by Transaction B can be considered as a ‘Lost Update’.



Dirty Read – This is when the data which is changed by one transaction (Uncommitted) is accessed by a different transaction. All isolation levels except for the ‘Read Uncommitted’ are protected against ‘Dirty Reads’.



Non Repeatable Read – This is when a specific set of data which is accessed more than once in one transaction (Transaction A) and between these accesses, it’s being updated or deleted by another transaction (Transaction B). The repeatable read, serializable, and snapshot isolation levels protect a transaction from non-repeatable reads.



Phantom Read – This is when two queries in the same transaction, against the same table, use the same ‘WHERE’ clause, and the query executed last returns more rows than the first one. Only the serializable and snapshot isolation levels protect a transaction from phantom reads.



In order to solve the above mentioned concurrency issues, SQL Server uses the following type of locks.

  • Shared or S-locks - Shared locks are sometimes referred to as read locks. There can be several shared locks on any resource (such as a row or a page) at any one time. Shared locks are compatible with other shared locks.
  • Exclusive or X-locks - Exclusive locks are also referred to as write locks. Only one exclusive lock can exist on a resource at any time. Exclusive locks are not compatible with other locks, including shared locks.
  • Update or U-locks - Update locks can be viewed as a combination of shared and exclusive locks. An update lock is used to lock rows when they are selected for update, before they are actually updated. Update locks are compatible with shared locks, but not with other update locks.

Please refer to the following link to get more information regarding lock types.

As I have mentioned earlier, the type of lock which the SQL server will be acquired depends on the active transactions isolation level. I will briefly describe each isolation level a bit further.

Read Committed Isolation Level – This is the default isolation level for new connections in SQL Server. This makes sure that dirty reads do not occur in your transactions. If the connection uses this isolation level, and if it encounters a dirty row while executing a DML statement, it’ll wait until the transaction which owns that row has been committed or rolled back, before continuing execution further ahead.



Read Uncommitted Isolation level - Though this is not highly recommended by experts, it's better to consider about it too. It may result in a 'dirty read', but when correctly used it could provide great performance benefits.

You should consider using this isolation level only in routines where the issue of dirty reads is not a problem. Such routines usually return information that is not directly used as a basis for decisions. A typical example where dirty reads might be allowed is for queries that return data that are only used in lists in the application (such as a list of customers) or if the database is only used for read operations.

The read uncommitted isolation level is by far the best isolation level to use for performance, as it does not wait for other connections to complete their transactions when it wants to read data that these transactions have modified. In the read uncommitted isolation level, shared locks are not acquired for read operations; this is what makes dirty reads possible. This fact also reduces the work and memory required by the SQL Server lock manager. Because shared locks are not acquired, it is no problem to read resources locked by exclusive locks. However, while a query is executing in the read uncommitted isolation level, another type of lock called a ‘schema stability lock’ (Sch-S) is acquired to prevent Data Definition Language (DDL) statements from changing the table structure. Below is an example of the behavior of this isolation level.



Repeatable Read Isolation Level - In this isolation level, it guarantees that dirty reads do not happen in your transaction. Also it makes sure that if you execute/issue two DML statements against the same table with the same where clause, both queries will return the same results. But this isolation level will protect against updates and deletes of earlier accessed rows, but not the inserts, which is known as ‘Phantom’ rows concurrency problem. Note that phantom rows might also occur if you use aggregate functions, although it is not as easy to detect.



Serializable Isolation Level – This guarantees that none of the aforesaid concurrency issues can occur. It is very much similar to the ‘repeatable read isolation level’ except that this prevents the ‘phantom read’ also. But use of this isolation level increases the risk of having more blocked transactions and deadlocks compared to ‘Repeat Read’. However it will guarantee that if you issue two DML statements against the same table with the same WHERE clause, both of them will return exactly the same results, including same number of row count. To protect the transaction from inserts, SQL Server will need to lock a range of an index over a column that is included in the WHERE clause with shared locks. If such an index does not exist, SQL Server will need to lock the entire table.


Snapshot Isolation Level – In addition to the SQL’s standard isolation levels, SQL 2005 introduced ‘Snapshot Isolation Level’. This will protect against all the above mentioned concurrency issues, like the ‘Serializable Isolation Level’. But the main difference of this is, that it does not achieve this by preventing access to rows by other transaction. Only by storing versions of rows while the transaction is active as well as tracking when a specific row was inserted.

To illustrate this I will be using a test database. It’s name is ‘SampleDB’. First you have to enable the ‘Snapshot Isolation Level’ prior using it

alter database SampleDB set allow_snapshot_isolation on;
alter database SampleDB set read_committed_snapshot off;

Now we’ll create a sample table and insert few records.

create table SampleIsolaion(
id int,
name varchar(20),
remarks varchar(20) default ''

insert into SampleIsolaion (id,name,remarks)
select 1, 'Value A', 'Def' union
select 2, 'Value B', 'Def'




Read Committed Snapshot Isolation Level – This can be considered as a new implementation of the ‘Read Committed’ isolation level. When this option is set, this provides statement level read consistency and we will see this using some examples in the post. Using this option, the reads do not take any page or row locks (only SCH-s: Schema Stability locks) and read the version of the data using row versioning by reading the data from tempdb. This option is set at the database level using the ALTER DATABASE command

I will illustrate the use of this isolation level with a sample. First enable the required isolation level.

alter database SampleDB set read_committed_snapshot on;
alter database SampleDB set allow_snapshot_isolation on;

Now lets create a table and populate it with few sample data.

create table sample_table(
id int,
descr varchar(20),
remarks varchar(20)

insert into sample_table
select 1,'Val A','Def' union
select 2,'Val B','Def'

Now open two query windows in SQL Server Management Studio.

--Window 1
begin tran
update sample_table set descr = 'Val P', remarks = 'Window 1' where id = 1


Without committing execute the following in the second window

--Window 2
begin tran
set transaction isolation level read committed
select * from sample_table

And you can see, even without committing, it’ll read from the older values, from the row versions which were created in the tempdb. If it was only the ‘Read Commited’ isolation level without the ‘Read Committed Snapshot’ option turned on, this select statement would have been locked.